- Windeltest: Nateen Combi
- Verlosung: SpecialKids.Company KayCey Vests
- Windelzubehör: Der große Onesie-Vergleich – Teil 14 – SpecialKids.Company
Back then I always wanted to do a proper test of the Nateen Combi diapers, but then this opportunity was snatched away when the only German distributor closed its doors and shortly thereafter other vendors in Europe also stopped carrying the product line due to the transition from foil to a breathable outer surface (Guess which side those resellers were on when it comes to that preference! ;-) ). As a result, I was ever only able to do a shortened version of a test thanks to some leftover pieces the folks at Diaper Minister sent me.
I never lost sight of “doing it right” and so I patiently waited for my next chance and that arose when I stumbled upon a new supplier called Smartlifetime.com. You gotta hand it to the Belgians – when it comes to the availability of incontinence products they certainly are at the forefront of it, at least here in Europe. Of course that’s easy for them, with some manufacturing and import companies also heaving headquarters and factories in that little country.
Wanting to be thorough about it, I went the full mile and got all absorption levels and in addition one of them in the two sizes relevant to me, size M and L. First lets explore the absorption part.
Ranging from the weakest to strongest absorption rating the individual levels are called Soft, Plus, Maxi and Ultra, respectively. Since every pack contains exactly ten pieces you can already get a feel for what to expect just by gauging the package sizes. This becomes even more apparent when you place them directly side by side. The two lowest levels are about equal in package size, but the Maxi and Ultra have each different dimensions. Naturally, these will again be different across sizes, so you might have a bit of a problem when it comes to stacking them up in your garage or whatever you may use as your storage facility if you mix & match different versions.
Taking a specimen from each package and stacking them (flattened out under pressure with a heavy bathroom tile in my case) is somewhat inconclusive with regards to distinguishing the levels just visually. If someone just showed you a picture, you couldn’t really tell how thick each absorption level is. You only get a better impression once you hold each one in your hand and feel how it responds to pressure and how it flip-flops around a bit more or a bit less depending on the actual variant. Part of this problem is the rather inconsistent product appearance. Allow me to elaborate and linger on that a bit.
According to their own website, Nateen have their products manufactured in three different factories in China and it shows unfortunately, not in a good way. Let’s discard the Soft version on the leftmost position in the above image having a foil panel for the time being. Clearly I ended up with a leftover package from the transitional phase and current production runs would look like the other three items.
If you look closely at those, you see that each one is distinctly different in terms of how it is folded, how it got squeezed/ compressed in the package, where the fader-type wetness indicator strips are placed. Even the cellulose fluff has a slightly different coloration in the Plus model. That’s definitely not what I would call consistent branding. Don’t even get me started on how wrinkled some of the diapers are on the inside! You could write this off as my usual niggles, of course, and it shouldn’t affect the usability, should it? Unfortunately it kinda does. Each absorption level seems to give a different user experience based on the mix of components and ingredients. Allow me to tiptoe through each one of them.
The Soft version is basically your “use once (or twice) and then throw away” version as it would most commonly be used in stationary medical care where there’s always someone at hand that can change the diaper. For most people reading this blog it’s therefore probably not the most relevant. Having ended up with the intermediate version, my biggest complaint here would have been that the adhesive tapes were a bit weak, but this could be totally be due to the package having sat in storage for too long. During the short time you would be wearing this the behavior is predictable enough and the product reasonably retains its shape, being that you can only push so far with filling it up.
I used the Plus for those two or three hours in the evening between showering and actually going to bed and whatever one does during that time like watching TV. Things get a bit odd with this one “on the last mile”, as it were. Up to a certain point it behaves pretty much like the Soft and feels comfortable, but beyond this mark it starts to feel more and more mushy with every drop you squeeze into it. I also noticed that a considerable amount of vapor seeped through the outer surface, leaving lots of condensation droplets on my plastic pants. Ergo it would be logical to never go without those, as this moisture would make things very uncomfortable when it goes directly into your onesie or textile underpants.
The Maxi in my opinion is the best balanced of all the versions. As you would expect and as its name implies the amount of liquid it can hold is considerable and I always found it to be more than sufficient even when out of home for a bit longer. In particular I liked that this model never actually feels saggy and in fact somewhat firm as I’m used to from my daily go-to product Attends Slip Regular or others like Tena Slip. It seems to me that this also avoids the issue with the condensed liquid.
The Ultra should add that extra bit of even more absorption on top, but strangely falls back into Plus territory when it comes how it actually feels. My impression is that just adding more absorbent material to the pad once again doesn’t work and while on many other products of that ilk I have criticized them being too hard and thus screwing up absorbency, here it is the exact opposite. For my taste after a while things got a bit too soggy and saggy, so I tended to change my diaper even if presumably the product could have sustained yet another shot of pee (or more).
The oddities and slight quirks with the appearance continue across different sizes as well as is evident in the picture below. Once again a case of factory A vs. factory B, I suppose. Additionally there’s a confusing disparity with the sizes themselves when compared to other products and established standard measurements.
The size M adheres to those standards pretty well – at about 65 cm panel width and 78 cm transversal length front to back it’s pretty much in the range you would find on a Tena, Attends, etc. product, covering the usual 80 to 110 cm circumference. The size L on the other hand exceeds those standard specs and in fact comes across more like an XL. Its front-to-back length is around 98 cm instead of the more common 90 cm, the panel width 83 cm instead of 78 cm. Those little bits here and there add up.
The good news in all of that is of course that if you are caught in the “gap” between L and XL you might be presented with a chance here to go with the smaller product while still being able to wear it comfortably. These observations also make me wonder what the actual XL version might be like. Perhaps I will buy a pack one day just to satisfy my curiosity.
For me wearing the size L is a bit awkward as there is seemingly no way to get it fixated as I would like. Admittedly, though, this could simply be a case of needing more practice, i.e. having to buy a few more packs to figure things out. The biggest issue in my case is that it ends up to high on the waist line and then the old chain of cause and effect kicks in – my belly pushes things out, the diaper slides down and overall there is just too much air in the crotch region to really feel safe.
As always my primary testing efforts were focused on size M. In addition to what has been said about the absorption levels and sizes already, there are a few more things worth mentioning. The first would be the shape of the absorbent pad. It’s identical across the whole range and thankfully isn’t “over-optimized” with the sideways extensions in the front and back not having trimmed to a strip. I love myself some good bum coverage and this product is therefore highly suitable for people with fecal incontinence issues. There’s a high likelihood everything will stay sealed in beyond your buttocks and not come out left and right of your butt crack.
While the basic shape and fit are just fine, the material of the outer surface is rather thin and tends to wear out after a certain time and amount of liquid in your diaper. This almost inevitably means that you may need to check and re-fasten your tapes at some point, which however then could also damage the surface when you have to tear the tapes off an all too moist product. Hmmm… It’s an imperfect world, but this is not how things should be.
The tapes are pretty much standard fare, but their being entirely white makes it at times difficult to figure out where to pull in a situation like described above. On a few occasions they also were reluctant to come off their backing foil when first putting on the diaper, so I managed to pull of their socket/ anchoring tape that is supposed to hold them on the shell a couple of times. Because the tapes are also kinda stiff and thick, you sometimes don’t even notice. In any case, you have to be careful.
Overall this is by no means a bad product, but it has issues that can’t be ignored. The inconsistent branding is a minor one, though you still have to ask “Why ?“. Companies like Hartmann or SCA/ Essity (Tena) go out of their way to provide the same experience even when products are produced in different facilities all across the globe, so it seems just weird they can’t manage the same in their factories that are relatively close by one another in China. Quality management, anyone?
The fit and softness of the product are once more a matter of individual preference. I prefer almost harness-like, tight diapers that are not too soft, others may be just the opposite and want things super soft. What cannot be debated, however, are things like possibly having to adjust your tapes halfway through the wearing time. This definitely needs to be addressed. While I still think that something has been lost or gone awry in the transition from a foil-based product to one with a breathable surface, not all is lost.
My personal favorite is the Maxi as it hits all the right beats and simply works. The others are kind of okay-ish. For me, anyway. Your own testing may skew in a different direction and the good part is that you can do so on a modest budget. Since only ten pieces are in every pack, the resulting prices per pack are low enough. You could even throw in one of them just to pad out your purchase and get entitlement for free shipping, should you come up short of whatever value a distributor may have set as the threshold…
As I wrote in my latest article, here’s another little giveaway for you. Two lucky winners can win one of two available KayCey Vest diaper suits/ special needs garments in size 176 (age 15-16). The contest is open until June 15, 2018 and after that date the winners will be contacted to provide a physical address to have their prizes shipped to them.
Just fill out the contact form below and indicate which model you would prefer in case of a win. Note that only the two examples are available in the size indicated. No substitutes or alternate prizes, so make sure you would be able to wear the onesies or know someone who might enjoy them. Multiple entries are allowed and prizes will be shipped to wherever you are using the cheapest possible method. Additional charges and fees may apply for non-EU residents. Have fun!
Privacy Info: By participating in the contest you agree to allow storing and processing your contact info until such time the winners have been successfully contacted and the prizes have been sent out. After this date the data will be immediately deleted. Your info will be kept private and not be shared with any third parties. You may request deletion of your data at any point before the deadline if you change your mind.
The search for the perfect onesie at times feels like the “Iron Triangle”. You know, that thing where if in an equilateral triangle the center represents the ideal state and the sides are rigidly constrained, the more you move one of the corners towards the center, the more the others move further away. It’s on a general level most often used as a good way to visualize the relationship of cost vs. quality vs. price.
Translated to the world of diaper suits/ bodysuits this can be applied in a multitude of ways. At one time a poor fit might nullify other positive aspects of a product, other times simple sloppy manufacturing may make the best intentions go for naught and yet another time excessive pricing may prevent strong market penetration and a path to glory.
For me personally one of the biggest hiccups always is color choice and acceptable sizing for grown-ups, so I was more than looking forward to getting my hands on the KayCey Vests from SpecialKids.Company after someone casually mentioned them on a forum and I started investigating. Let’s see what they have in store for us.
Despite my not minding flamboyant colors and colorful patterns most of the time even when I’m exposed e.g. during physical therapy, we all have those moments where we need to take a more serious approach to the matter. That is the case for people who might not think it’s that cute at all when elderly ladies benevolently smile at your printed onesie peeking out from under your sweater, but it’s also important for kids to minimize the risk of being victims of bullying or being ridiculed.
The SpecialKids.Company suits fill that requirement quite well. To begin with, all colors are slightly subdued, so they don’t pop that much. This in particular applies to the pink and sky blue variants, of course. They both lean towards a warm color interpretation, which makes them appear less aggressive while at the same time avoiding the “baby pastels” trap by not being too pale, either.
The sky blue in addition is matched to the typical color of British school uniforms’ polo shirts and together with the white version by choosing the respective polo type shape can be used as full substitutes for their regular counterparts on those uniforms. Other styles like the sleeveless variant may also be relevant any other standardized, unified clothing the school may require, e.g. sports.
For us adults the most relevant colors beyond white are likely the dark navy (blue) and grey versions. The latter variant features the mottled structure that is typical of grey sweat pants or for that matter other products using similar textiles, most often based on polyester. This should once more make it easy to combine the bodysuits with other apparel without anyone noticing right away.
The navy color for my taste is a bit too dark and has a slight cyan tinge, meaning it appears almost black most of the time. That’s not a terrible issue, it just may not match your blue jeans as well as you may have hoped or look too dark in contrast to some other pieces of clothing you intend to wear. Yupp, the curse of being fashion-conscious. ;-) On that note, I definitely wouldn’t mind seeing more colors or even something like the dual colored versions featured in SpecialKids.Company‘s older Wonsie product line such as a grey suit with black sleeves or vice versa. Perhaps they’ll revive those color schemes.
I admit I’ll never fully understand the British age-based size system. It’s imprecise and open to individual interpretation by the vendors and thus just as confusing as the American letter-based system trying to categorize everything into S to XL. I much prefer the French/ German system based on genuine body height in centimeters. Therefore for this review I went with the largest available size targeted at ages 15-16 or size 176, respectively, just to be on the safe side.
This decision turned out to be about right, though admittedly I might in fact try one size smaller next time. I’ve always preferred a very tight fit and the KayCey Vests are shaped very spaciously even for a chubby boy like me. That is of course totally subjective and a matter of individual tastes.
First and foremost these products are made for children with special needs in mind. Those kiddos might prefer things not to be so snug and want greater freedom of movement; wheelchair-bound people may need those extra centimeters to cover their skin, users with feeding tubes conversely may need some space to shove their clothes aside for easy access to their stomach region and ultimately stretching out a polo style onesie too much might look totally iffy, after all. ;-)
Given the size I chose, there’s enough room left to feel comfortable and not bump into issues like the snappers zapping away because of too much tension. At my 1.80 meters height and a slightly stocky figure there are no issues whatsoever. Even moving my arms during physical therapy has no ill effects unlike with some other products that are a tad too short when it comes to upper body length.
In my opinion the sleeve length of the short could be a bit longer. I get that you may not want things to get too lofty, especially when people need assistance for dressing and things could tangle up, but slightly more extended sleeves would be more convincing for the onesies to pass as conventional T-shirts. It’s literally just that one inch…
The lower section is designed to cover your behind and extend down to the upper thighs. This ensures that any incontinence products you may be wearing are fully covered and hidden and of course it keeps you warm. The images may give an exaggerated “big butt” impression because the diaper suit tapers out, but it’s really not that. When wearing the product, it follows your contours naturally.
As an alternative to my preferred T-shirt style there are the already heavily mentioned polo style and a sleeveless/ tank top version. SpecialKids.Company were kind enough to include some examples for this article in my order and you lucky people can win them in a little giveaway (see the separate follow-up post).
I tried them on briefly, but they are not really my thing. I just can’t see myself wearing a polo suit all the time, no matter what the color. I also think if I were to use the tank top, I would like the arm holes to actually be larger, i.e. start lower instead of directly in the armpits. The rationale here of course is to make it more difficult for the kids to inadvertently undress themselves. Still, I think that for adults it may be useful to allow some more leeway and a looser fit, all my critical views and personal preference aside.
As a final note: All types of KayCey Vests are also available with a dedicated tube access window as a means of controlling PEG / tube access on people who are dependent on such stuff. In addition to standard use cases like feeding tubes or those pesky cables of electronic monitoring devices, this possibly could also be handy for treatments like peritoneal dialysis and so on. The mere mention of these words makes me shudder, though, so I’m just as glad I’m not dependent on any of this yet and won’t elaborate on it too deeply. I’ll just mention that it’s available for the sake of painting the full picture.
I’m always a bit skeptical with those almost romper-like suits and their protruding legs. There’s always the chance the buttons may be placed less than ideally and this could have bad consequences like the snappers being a nightmare to button up or them sliding on each other and getting caught, only to then tear open inadvertently at the most inconvenient time. This isn’t the case here.
I suppose the likelihood of these incidents is a matter of a) how far down the leg pieces actually reach, b) the number and placement of the buttons and c) their strength.
With the leg extensions actually not being this massively long and the coverage being more equal to conventional short “tighty whitey” briefs, case a) is probably taken care of already. The buttons will still end up as a single straight row in your crotch area. At worst, the outermost snappers could end up buried in your groins and feel a bit uncomfortable.
With regards to b), five buttons should sufficiently take care of the matter. As I found out over the course over this article series, this seems to be some kind of sweet spot, anyway. Three is definitely not enough, four often lead to strange warping down there and only five, placed relatively close together, seem to provide enough strength to keep things smooth and reliably sealed up.
Odd numbers also have the advantage of being able to start in the middle and not mess up the order. As much as I like my Sanetta onesies for instance, I occasionally still misalign the front and back rows and then end up only closing three buttons with an unused half element on either side being left. You guessed it – you have to start over then.
In addition to this simple intuitive logic of odd vs. even numbers SpecialKids.Company are trying to facilitate this even further by having the central locating popper in a different color. Currently this is their corporate purple, but since on some color combinations it is difficult to recognize, I would love to see alternative colors for better contrast in future production runs. It may be difficult to accommodate depending on actual production numbers and cost efficiency, but one can dream. To illustrate this, I have mocked up an image showing how it could look.
If you are fully able to dress yourself it may of course not be that relevant. I personally rely on my fingertip sensors mostly and don’t stand in front of a mirror or bend forward like crazy just to see the buttons. On the other hand I can see how it might make things a little easier for parents, nurses, kindergarten teachers and so on when they help the little ones get dressed.
Returning to point c) of our little hypothesis, this can easily be answered in a positive way as well. The buttons here are extremely strong, even if they are “just” of the 7 mm type where others use the larger 9 mm ones. In fact it’s a good thing the area where they are fixated has an extra liner tissue sandwiched in. It’s also beneficial that this area is a separate appendage and unlike elsewhere the buttons are not just hammered into the regular leg seams. One can only hope this never happens, but in case you really rip out a button, this would make it much easier to repair things, including possibly sewing on a new strip if you really shredded the original one for good.
Where there’s lots of light, there inevitably is some shadow at least and that comes in the form of the cloth perhaps being a bit too soft to truly hold up a larger adult diaper on its own. It’s quite likely all fine up to a certain size and a specific thickness/ weight, but in particular for the ages 12 and up I could well see that some extra strength being needed. The extended leg parts take a bit off that burden with their friction acting as a “stopper”, but they can’t compensate everything. This is also the reason why I definitely want to try a smaller size to get a tighter fit with more resilience that may counter this issue.
In the long run, though, I think this needs a proper solution, at least for those people not wanting to wear extra fixation garments underneath. Perhaps this means sewing in an extra textile strip to act as a belt, perhaps it means double-layering the cloth, perhaps it means branching out into a completely new product line for adolescents and grown-ups. I don’t know. In any case, this is more or less again one of those adult niggles, not an inherent flaw in the product. You know, different needs and those diapers getting proportionately heavier on larger people…
Potential issues with insufficient diaper load-bearing notwithstanding, the supple cloth is otherwise something to love. It’s a textile similar to the one used by Onesies Downunder, consisting of a mix of 95% cotton with the remaining percentage being Elastane. The obvious benefits are a high adaptability to different body proportions and good shape retention (unless you really ruin things by washing or ironing too hot ;-) ).
On the subject of washing – color stability and durability of the cloth are just what you would expect. Those fine cloths tend to be much more robust than one gives them credit for and since here they are a full dye, solid color, this is even less of an issue. If you follow washing instructions you should not run into any problems. I can’t vouch for extreme situations, though, since I tend to not spill ketchup that might necessitate aggressive high-temperature washing. Rather the opposite – I always have to be careful to not let my pieces turn grey too much when I use washing agents all too sparingly at low temperatures.
No matter which approach to laundry you prefer, it’s more likely that the hot foil print on the inside will come off long before the products have reached their end of life. In addition to containing the pertinent size and manufacturing information this part also has an area where you can fill in your name with a textile marker. This would be useful to avoid mix-ups in cloakrooms at schools with uniforms or residential care homes with multiple people having their laundry done by “someone in charge” and where it would help to sort the pieces after laundry.
The finely knit textile is very gentle to the skin and shouldn’t become a burdensome, itchy mess at any point. There are other measures in place to deal with this exact problem as well. Firstly there are totally no sewn-in clothing tags, which I find a very smart decision. There just never is a good place to put them and after a while they either look totally shabby or drive you bonkers with their sharp edges scratching on your skin (especially with the plastic-y type). Anyone who has ever bought some piece of apparel from a big international brand knows how outrageously tough it can be to get rid of those stacks of tags in like twenty languages even if you have shaved them down to a thin strip and removed them almost completely.
This leaves us with the seams, which if not done right can be just as much a pain – quite literally. We all have those days where we wake up in the morning and have those annoying pressure marks, whether it’s from conventional pajamas or your favorite unicorn onesie. Now imagine how that may feel if you are (partially) immobilized and can’t simply change position or need to wear specific medical braces, harnesses, casts and so on. SpecialKids.Company tackle this by keeping the seams as flat as possible.
To that end two strategies are employed: The stitching is applied in a horizontal way using flat-locked seams (which, BTW also looks very decorative and pleasing) and where that is not possible, converging edges like the rims of the neck hole are placed in such a way that the thick parts are mostly on the outside and the inner seams are also cleaned up with flat stitching. Of course there are limits to how far this can be taken and in some places you can see that this is also hard on the seamstresses who put the pieces together.
While the overall quality is good, you occasionally notice minor glitches and inaccuracies, especially in areas where multiple seams meet and you wonder if this couldn’t have been done differently. I’m not going to go out on a limb here, though, since I’m not rocking the sewing machine and can only judge this in an abstract “How would I do it?” sense.
Despite being a bespoke/ specially designed special needs garment, the pricing for the KayCey Vests is more than reasonable. Pricing is tiered and relates to the size/ age denomination and begins at around 15 GPB (17 Euros) for the small sizes up to 21 GBP (24 Euros) for the largest ones. With foreign currencies the values fluctuate based on daily exchange rates and with the Brexit looming nobody knows where the journey goes, but that is to say it’s not unaffordable or super-expensive.
Availability is generally not much of an issue. SpecialKids.Company always appear to have a sufficient supply in stock based on my irregular checks of their online store and following them on Facebook. Actual delivery on the other hand gave me a bit of a head scratch.
Being outside the UK can end up confusing due to international shipping agents/ intermediary logistics companies getting involved. SpecialKids.Company send their packages through Hermes, which seems simple enough. At the same time, though, despite the same name, the British version seems to have very little to do with the one based here in Germany, so I ended up getting confusing mails from one of those aforementioned service companies (whose name totally eludes me now) that were not much use for actually keeping track of where the package was. Sentences like “Your package has been processed at the destination parcel center.” don’t really mean much, so unsurprisingly the delivery driver rang the doorbell when I didn’t quite expect it. Yes, I’m one of those people who keep watching out for those colorful trucks and ideally love to know the delivery time down to the minute. ;-)
All of this is not SpecialKids.Company‘s fault, though. Things could be just fine now and all issues smoothed out with this merely being an unexpected hiccup in the system. Still, perhaps they will offer an alternative shipping method via DHL or another big player one day to make this more predictable for us impatient people.
Compared to many so-so entries in my article series, this is downright bliss. The KayCey Vests are not completely perfect, either (if there is even such a thing), but considerable thought has gone into the design and manufacturing and it carries through to the final product. What’s left is to optimize the larger sizes more for adults and expand the product range with more variants, other colors and all that good stuff.
I’m also hoping that this will develop into a reliable source for these products here in Europe, even if the current state of affairs in Great Britain and its future has a big question mark next to it. There’s plenty of ways to find and get these products – directly via their own web shop, by following the links on their Facebook pages or on Amazon (including the German platform). All that said, you should definitely put these products on your “Wanted” list and give them a try. Your chance to do just that totally for free is just around the corner in our little contest…
With some considerable ground already covered and several of the “big players” in the field of incontinence related products already having had their due, the next one in line is Tena.
Like it has been the case with other skincare product series, Tena‘s offering is equally uneven and sort of incomplete. Things seem never to come together in one place, or in this case from a single vendor, respectively. You always have to mix and match. The part that Tena brings to the table are some paper-based products that aren’t that bad and perhaps an interesting barrier product. We’ll find out more on that later.
As far as commonalities between the products go, the most noticeable is a lemongrass scent which depending on the situation and specific product can be anything from okay to pretty annoying. Its intensity depends a lot on how long stays on your skin, so it’s more bearable when it quickly dissipates after a shower and in turn much less acceptable when your entire body smells of it, at least for me. Depending on your preference it may be just fine, but I’m hyper-sensitive to odours and get easily aggravated over them.
The package designs are contemporary and almost stylish, yet the color coding at times feels a bit unnecessary, given the limited selection of items. It’s not too much of a stretch of imagination to envision them all being just blue, even more so since the differentiation in some areas is limited, to say the least. Imagine a care nurse under stress taking a shampoo cap from the storage room instead of wet washing gloves and only realising the mistake in the patient’s room after a long walk! ;-)
The water-based cleaning department is represented by a single product – a combined shampoo and shower gel. Matching the color of the sticker on the bottle and the pump at the top it has been tinted green, but that’s pretty much all there is. I found it easy enough to use and it’s economical, lasting for quite a bit of time, but it has no specific hidden powers or secret ingredients that would e.g. make it easier to get rid of zinc cream.
Waterless cleaning features the same products commonly employed by pretty much everyone – a wet wipes, variations on the theme with wet washing gloves, foam spray and an emulsion. The latter comes in two package sizes, one as a 250 ml tube and the other as a 500 ml dispenser bottle. The wash cream is pretty “neutral” in the sense that it is neither particularly oily nor very water-y, providing a good middle-ground for most of these tasks. It is also very mild, so there is no risk of skin irritations should you not get it off right away. Sometimes this happens when I get a phone call at inconvenient times and then wander around my flat half-naked with these products still on my skin.
The foam is a different matter, and to be brutally honest, I found it mostly useless. It is extremely unstable, barely leaving you a blink-of-an-eye moment to apply it correctly. Its bubbles begin to collapse immediately as soon as they hit the skin, leaving you with a wet puddle. This behavior also makes it impossible to apply the product indirectly via your fingers – that dab of foam literally melts on your fingertips. To make matters worse the spray can again is of the stand-on-your-head variety as opposed to what would be a more useful perpendicular nozzle. Still, even if it were, getting the foam where you need it would require some practice and experience. As it is currently, this product needs some major attention and is clearly a candidate for a major overhaul.
The wet wipes are a bit of an oddity as they feel a bit “dry” when taken out of the package even though they actually aren’t. Of course I’m not complaining about this, as I’m not friends with soaking wet wipes. So arguably I should perhaps just shut up about it and accept things as they are. I’ll be the first to admit that. ;-) One advantage of this perceived dryness is the need to really proactively rub the wipes on the skin instead of just letting the cloth slide. Therefore the actual cleansing effect should in fact be even better. The downside could be that for people with very thin or sensitive skin this could already be too much and they could experience painful abrasions or their coarse skin cracking open. This is really a “your mileage may vary” thing in the end.
The wet wash gloves are an extension of the previous item and where Hartmann ask you to use up to eight of these things, Tena only require five of them by ways of a somewhat convoluted, or if you will elaborate, scheme of using the front and back sides of a single glove. Which is better is for the practitioners to decide since naturally for our purpose of cleaning the intimate regions inbetween diaper changes just one glove will do just fine most of the time. Here you even get to pick between the standard scent and an odourless variant.
Finally, there’s the shampoo cap mentioned earlier. Since I have very short, cropped hair I haven’t found a good excuse to actually use it, so I can’t offer any first-hand experience. This is by all means intended as a hair fresh-up for bedridden or otherwise immobilized people who may be too weak to make it to the bathroom. I would imagine, though, that in a pinch it could be used when you’re stuck camping out in nature or on a summer festival and access to water is limited. The product can be used both warmed up in a microwave or cold fresh out of the bag.
This section is one of the more unique things about Tena‘s portfolio that so far I like a lot. Okay, granted, you can find these paper products from other manufacturers, too, but typically they are more marketed for medical use than homecare/ incontinence care and they may not be available in retail, but only in bulk/ large quantities e.g. for hospitals. What also makes this particular product line stand out is that they come in boxes. Yes, you heard me right, plain old cardboard boxes with die-cut tear-open fronts that make it easy to take out an item even if you only pincer it with your oily, dirty fingers. No awkward foil bags, no nonsense. You really will appreciate what a godsend this can be when you are in a situation where you just want to reach for that dry wipe without contaminating something else. The only real downside is the bulkiness, but I’m sure you can make place on your shelf or bedstand.
The first, and at this point having become mundane, item are the washing gloves. They are available as a foil-lined version and one without. Just look at those huge numbers! Used sparingly, a single box could last you half a year. From a practical standpoint, Tena‘s gloves feel a bit stiff so even if you only want to (mis-)use them as a dry wipe, ever so slightly moisturising them with just a drop of water will make them more comfortable to use.
On to the next – so far easily one of my favorite products in this series – the dry Soft Wipes. These are universally usable wipes for all kinds of things. They can be used dry, but just as well soaking wet. Their texture is much denser and firmer than Seni‘s Air-Laid tissues, yet they are almost as soft and gentle. I often use them as a way of getting rid of excess moisture after having used wet wipes or after having had to do a thorough wet cleaning after messy accidents in the posterior regions. The smaller version of the product is way sufficient, but you can of course indulge and get the larger flavor just as well.
The other significant product is Cellduk, a more conventional multi-layered paper product akin to napkins, Tempos/ paper hankies or the similar tissues of this sort used in the medical business e.g. as sterile swabs after blood tests to stop the bleeding once the needle has been pulled out. As such the product shares the rather coarse and rough feel of this product and while it’s possible I would not necessarily use it dry. Similar to the wash gloves this works much better if it is a bit damp. It becomes more malleable, allowing you to literally get better into every (butt-)crack. Due to its layered nature it has also a pretty good absorbency, making it an ideal candidate for wiping away all kinds of splotches and stains, which of course can include mundane household stuff like wine or ketchup as well.
Truth be told, none of these paper products are admittedly essential and there’s nothing wrong with holding on to your cheap household paper towels, but I find especially the Soft Wipes a nice alternative when dealing with my poopy problems. It’s more efficient to have a single large, stable piece rather than using up endless sheets of toilet paper or being afraid to poke holes into cheap paper towels, if you get my meaning. As such I’d be ready to buy this product again every time. On some level even the price would balance itself out, depending on how much toilet paper/ kitchen towels you actually use/ have to use. To me it sometimes feels like I buy a family pack of this stuff every week…
The skincare department is as sparsely populated as pretty much every other area and only features two items – a lotion and a thicker cream. Neither of the two were particularly suitable for my skin type. Understandably the cream is aimed at people older than me, but even so I found it unnecessarily greasy. I have serious doubts that it would easily get absorbed even into the most dry and brittle elderly skin. On the other hand the lotion feels a bit too dry and sticky for its own good. It just doesn’t flow nicely on the skin and I inevitably ended up using an extra dab here and there to cover up spots that I didn’t catch right away. The advantage here is of course that it doesn’t feel sweaty like with some other products, so I’m a bit torn whether that’s all fine and good or if it needs to be changed.
The protective products are going to be a bit of a walk of shame for me because I honestly totally forgot about the zinc cream. At the time when I received my samples it wasn’t available anywhere and as I went along with my testing efforts, shooting the photos and other preparations for the article I lost sight of the matter. It only re-entered my conscious thoughts when I sat down for writing the text. I would argue, though, that you can’t really do much wrong with a zinc ointment, so unless I’m missing something fundamental, it probably will not be worth worrying about it too much. Still, there’s always a chance for those follow-up articles, of course.
As a saving grace (and also saving my deriere for this article), the alternative transparent barrier cream is actually pretty good. I was a bit skeptical, since it is as thick as honey on the verge of crystallizing and also looks like that – a rich golden color. As a catch, this also requires quite a bit of strength to squeeze it out of the tube. Once you have successfully managed to get a portion on your fingers it will begin to melt nicely, though, so actually applying it to the regions you want to isn’t a problem. This goes to show how finely tuned the liquifying point is to the body temperature. Once in place, the film it creates is more or less a somewhat dull/ matte layer, which is neither particularly sticky nor very slide-y like with some other products. I actually quite like it, even more so since it stays put for extended durations without requiring to be renewed. It survives multiple diaper changes if you don’t do excessive cleaning inbetween and completely rub it off.
My overall impression with the Tena skincare line is quite similar to the one from Attends – if one thing is missing, it’s a consistent user experience and some products are almost unusable. At least I consider the cleaning foam spray a total dud. Thankfully the cellulose-based products and the barrier cream make more than up for it, but still – this shouldn’t happen with such a big brand. Once again this is quite a mixed bag.
Thanks to SCA/ Essity for providing the product samples for this article.
Life has a way of writing its own script and so despite my best intentions, post activity on this little blog of mine took another slump. I’m not gonna bore you with the details, but suffice it to say that from being hit with some unexpected paperwork to renovating my flat partially to delays in product releases and thus unavailability for reviews to my usual health issues there have been a couple of things contributing to this and messing with my schedule. I’m hoping that this will smooth out we have a more stable flow of articles again from now, as despite all the interference of course I haven’t been entirely lazy and still worked on stuff as best as I could.
As a start we’re going to have something short and simple by ways of the Forsite AM:PM. You may ask why this should be simple. The answer to that lies in the fact that we may already have discussed the product in some form here, or, if you will, at least one of its cousins in the form of the Comficare way, way back then. I’m consciously not saying that they are the exact same product, even though the similarities are massive. Still, there are differences as well and aside from explaining those, this review also gives me an opportunity to re-evaluate my views on some things, as with experience over the years they have changed somewhat.
When the Comficare was taken off the market, we all wondered where it went and whether it would come back. Apparently it went to Canada. ;-) At the time there was quite a debate and while even today on a logical level I perfectly understand the reasons for the cancellation, looking back at it I’d probably have a different opinion today. The fact of the matter is that, though not cheap, this product is perfectly affordable if you really want/ need it. Mind you, I’m saying that as a German where the product has been imported from China to Canada, from Canada to The Netherlands and then a package found its way to my humble home. That is to say there are a lot of surcharges on top of the original price at every step of the way and yet it is not impossible to treat yourself every once in a while to such a pack. Under those conditions it seems almost feasible they could have kept Comficare alive, but without deeper investigation of the original manufacturing/ OEM pricing even I can’t tell for certain.
There are still twelve or ten pieces in every pack for sizes M and L, respectively. Still no XL or other sizes in sight, though. For this re-review I had only size M available, but I might want to check out the L again one day. The measurements check out and are almost perfectly identical, making this yet another strong indicator hinting at the relationship to the Comficare. And that’s where it gets interesting.
This time around I found the fit much more acceptable. There are several contributing factors. The first is of course experience. Three years in the diaper-wearing “business” is quite a bit of time and I simply know much better how I want such products to sit on my body. That also goes for products I only use rarely or ones that are completely new to me. You could probably call it some sort of muscle memory that makes this almost an instinctive thing – you just know when something isn’t right while your body is gauging the sensory impression compared to your standard product you may use every day.
The other thing related to my body is that due to some unexplained metabolic issues I have lost and keep losing weight. It doesn’t hurt, but it’s not really intentional, either. I’m still stuffing my face with lots of chocolate and other things most people consider unhealthy and still, yet the kilos keep dropping. It’s a slow burn and I still have enough reserves, but at that rate I might turn into a sexy slender beast one day. ;-) Anyway, having less fat on your body certainly makes some things easier.
From a technical point of view there appear to be some improvements that help with the fit, too. Without a direct comparison it’s obviously hard to verify this quantifiably, but it seems to me that the product has gone through some revisions or the manufacturing process uses different materials based on current availability. The large foil sticker on the front panel seems much more flexible and thus the product adapts better. That doesn’t change the fact that due to the very wide part between the legs that acts like a stopper it still sits somewhat low and I might be served better using a size L, but I feel there is definitely some improvement here.
The other noticeable enhancement is the absorbent pad. Again, this may either be totally coincidental or an intentional revision, but it’s very welcome, no less. One of my bigger criticisms with the Comficare was that it began to smell noticeably after a while for the simple fact that the chemicals in the pad seemed to decompose. This happened even if you hadn’t really exhausted the full capacity, so it was definitely a process that mostly depended on the actual wearing time and things like body heat more than how stinky your urine was. This seems to have been rectified and I now have much less of an urge to rip of my diaper prematurely.
The rest is very much like I remember it from back then. True to its word, this is probably still the product with the highest overall absorption that is available on the market. There may be others that I don’t know yet, but for now I think this is the benchmark. The tiny enhancements have made this even better, so there’s really nothing to say against this product other than that it feels a bit old-fashioned at times from the overall shape to it being foil-based. As it turns out, that’s not always a bad thing and almost makes you wish there were more products like this available…
The space/ fantasy onesie from our little contest is now in the process of finding its new lucky owner. A winner has been drawn and if all goes well, as mail-laden rocket will be sent off to its new home (planet). Thanks to everyone who participated and no worries, the next giveaway is already lined up. That is in all sincerity no April Fool’s joke, so keep an eye out and tune in from time to time to not miss anything. Also happy Easter to everyone (or what remains of it)!
While most people who follow my blogs are quiet readers and that probably won’t change, occasionally someone steps forward and proactively gets in touch with me to offer some kind words and a bit of support. That’s how I got this space/ fantasy themed onesie intended to be reviewed for my onesies series. Unfortunately the size monster struck again and it is way too small for me, so I’m giving this well-intentioned, but unfortunately for me not usable present away.
The onesie is a size M and the model can be bought from ABDLFactory (among other things of course ;-) ). After checking, I figured that once again I probably would need an XL or at the very least an L. This means that this particular example is for smaller persons not taller than 1.7 m body height. The material is a mix of polyester fibre and Elasthane, so there is some room for variation. It should also take care of the onesie feeling cosy enough, despite appearing somewhat thin.
As the second picture clearly shows, the quality is pretty good with this article being almost perfectly symmetrical and no crooked seams. If you like that and the design is up your alley, then fill out the little registration form and maybe you are the lucky winner of our little draw:
The contest is closed and the contact form has been removed to prevent abuse. Thanks for your interest!
The contest is open to everyone as long as the shipping cost would exceed the value of the product, meaning everything continental Europe, the UK and EU countries in particular is probably okay. If you live somewhere exotic you can still participate, but you may need to (partially) cover extra shipping cost if it requires more than a simple padded envelope and a “heavy letter” fee. Deadline for entry is Sunday, April 1st 2018. The winner will be picked and notified shortly thereafter. Good luck to everyone!
Legal notice: By entering the contest you agree to the terms and conditions laid out before and allow your contact information to be stored until the winner has been successfully contacted and accepted his prize. After that date the data will be deleted/ destroyed in compliance with privacy regulations and accepted best practices.